If you are someone who enjoys ice in your drinks, you might be aware that a high-quality countertop ice maker can elevate your beverage experience significantly. For those who are not yet convinced, the investment in a premium ice maker can be surprising, but the benefits are undeniable. These machines excel at producing soft, chewable ice that enhances the enjoyment of cocktails and chilled drinks.
While there are many options available, one standout model has gained a reputation for its exceptional nugget ice production. After using a nugget ice maker for over two years, I can confidently say that returning to traditional ice cubes would be a challenge. These countertop machines not only generate ice much faster than conventional ice trays, but they are also surprisingly convenient. They can be placed anywhere with an electrical outlet and stored away when not in use. Most importantly, they prevent ice from absorbing unwanted odors from your freezer.
Having tested numerous countertop ice makers, I have concluded that investing in a specialized nugget ice maker is worthwhile for those who plan to keep it on their kitchen counter. My top recommendations below are both nugget ice makers. However, if you are looking for a more budget-friendly and portable option, there are several bullet ice makers that perform adequately, as you will discover in the following sections.
Nugget ice is incredibly versatile compared to the solid cubes produced by standard ice molds. It not only adds a delightful texture to cocktails, fizzy drinks, and refreshing beverages but also makes packing items on ice much easier due to its malleable nature. This type of ice can cover a larger surface area, making it ideal for various uses.
Top Choice for Nugget Ice: Premium Nugget Ice Maker
This premium nugget ice maker is renowned for producing the best chewable ice, often referred to as “Sonic-style” ice. It features a spacious ice drawer with a viewing window and boasts a sleek design.
Advantages: Produces high-quality, chewable nugget ice | Large capacity ice drawer | Modern aesthetic
Disadvantages: Higher price point | Can be noisy during operation | Cleaning cycle can be cumbersome
The ice produced by this machine is not solid like traditional ice cubes; instead, it consists of compressed ice flakes, making it soft and enjoyable to chew. This model is unique in its ability to create true nugget ice, which is often sought after in restaurants.
For households that consume a lot of ice or frequently host gatherings, opting for a model with a larger water reservoir is advisable. This feature minimizes the need for constant refills. Additionally, the machine’s Wi-Fi connectivity allows users to schedule ice production remotely, which is a great convenience for tech-savvy individuals.
Regular maintenance is essential to prevent mineral buildup and bacteria growth. The machine includes a built-in cleaning function, but it requires some effort to execute properly. While I may not adhere strictly to the recommended cleaning schedule, I have not encountered any issues with my unit.
Dimensions: 13.43″W x 17.5″D x 16.5″H
Ice production: Up to 24 lbs. of nugget ice in 24 hours
Another Excellent Nugget Ice Maker: Compact Nugget Ice Maker
This compact nugget ice maker is another fantastic option, producing delightful chewable ice quickly. While it may not match the texture of the top model, it still offers a satisfying ice experience.
Pros: Produces enjoyable nugget ice | Sleek design | Can connect directly to a water line
Cons: Higher price | Can be noisy during operation | Lacks a viewing window for the ice drawer
This model is user-friendly and has a more upscale appearance. It can be connected to a water line, eliminating the need for frequent refills. Although it is slightly taller than the previous model, it may not fit under all cabinets.
Dimensions: 17.2″D x 9.6″W x 16.7″H
Ice production: Up to 30 lbs. of ice in 24 hours
Selection and Testing Process for Ice Makers
In my evaluation, I focused on two primary types of countertop ice makers: nugget ice makers and bullet ice makers. After testing various models across different price ranges, I found that while bullet ice makers tend to be quite similar, nugget ice makers vary significantly in quality.
Nugget Ice Makers: The quality of ice produced by a nugget ice maker is often directly related to its price. While budget models exist, they typically do not produce the same quality of ice as higher-end machines. My testing emphasized the chewability and texture of the ice produced by each model.
Bullet Ice Makers: In contrast, bullet ice makers generally share similar designs and performance characteristics. Most models in the affordable range produce comparable ice shapes and sizes, making it easier to choose based on aesthetics or brand reputation.
Criteria for Judging Ice Makers
When evaluating ice makers, I considered several factors, including the speed of ice production and the capacity of the ice drawer. The actual ice production capacity is less important than the size of the ice basket, as this determines how much ice can be stored at once.
Additionally, I assessed the quality of the ice produced, whether it was nugget, clear, or bullet-shaped. The functionality of the ice drawer or basket was also crucial, as it should be insulated enough to keep ice cold for several hours.
Finally, I took into account the overall size and appearance of the machines, as well as their ease of setup and maintenance. Noise levels during operation were also noted, as many users express concerns about the sound produced by these machines.
Other Notable Countertop Ice Makers Tested
In addition to the top picks, I also explored other countertop ice makers that offer unique features or designs. These models cater to different preferences and budgets, ensuring that there is an option for everyone looking to enhance their ice-making experience.